Jim Hiller should be fired this week, and John Chayka should be the one standing at a podium explaining why the coach he hand-picked in June is finished 25 games into the job. The Maple Leafs lost 4-3 to Columbus on Saturday at Scotiabank Arena, their ninth straight loss (0-8-1), and they lost it the way they keep losing: holding a lead late, at home, with the coach afterward asking reporters, "We're getting tired of this one aren't we?"
Yes, they are. So is the building, which was chanting "Fire Hiller!" once the Blue Jackets went ahead.
The pattern belongs to the coach
Two nights before Columbus, Toronto blew a 3-0 lead to the Los Angeles Kings and lost in a shootout. On Saturday a 3-2 lead in the third period against the 28th-place Blue Jackets lasted until 15:40, when Matthew Knies, in his first game back in Toronto since the Leafs traded him on Sept. 28, tied it after a William Nylander turnover in the Toronto zone with under five minutes left. Zach Werenski scored the winner 52 seconds later, with 3:28 to go. Eight of the nine losses in this skid have come on home ice.
Hiller has already diagnosed the problem himself. "It's just been too many times where we've scored and the next shift they've scored," he said. "That's probably on me. I've got to find a better combination of players, it's happened too many times… I've never seen anything like it."
He's right. Finding the right combinations, and the right people on the ice when a game tightens late, is the core of the job. He named the failure, took ownership of it, and it kept happening anyway. A coach who's never seen anything like it is describing a problem he was hired to stop.
The minutes give him away
Look at how Hiller handled Nylander. The winger had gone five straight games without a point, his longest drought since February 2021, and was a minus-eight over that run, which is why Hiller dropped him to the third line for a game on Nov. 19. Two nights later Nylander logged 19:33. Gavin McKenna, the prized rookie Toronto took first overall in June, played 15:51.
Nylander did set up Teddy Blueger's second-period goal, so he was clearly in the game. But he was out there with under five minutes left, and the turnover on his stick became the tying goal. Demoting a player for his form and then trusting him with more ice time than your best young talent is incoherent, and incoherent is how a team ends up blowing leads on a loop.
About the laughing
The collapses have turned slapstick: score, then give it right back on the next shift. Plenty of people watching this team have moved from anger to gallows humor, and it's hard to blame them. A joke only stays funny when it keeps repeating, and repeating is exactly what the coach is paid to prevent. The players don't sound amused either. Jake McCabe summed up Saturday this way: "We just threw up all over ourselves pretty much and lose the game." When the dressing room and the stands both sound resigned, the bench has lost the argument.
Chayka owns the hire
Firing a coach 25 games in is an admission that the hire was wrong. It was wrong, and the admission belongs to Chayka. He fired Craig Berube on May 13, saying the club needed an "organizational shift," and made Hiller the 41st head coach in franchise history in June. As of this weekend that shift looks like an 8-14-3 team outside a playoff position, three losses from matching the franchise-record 11-game losing streak set in 2015.
Hiller has earned the firing. He's practically written the press release himself. Chayka has earned the scrutiny that comes next. Whoever he hires to replace Hiller is his second chance, and if that one fails too, he won't get a third.




